Welcome to the Slant, where you'll find reviews and original writings by the members of Martin Library's Teen Advisory Board.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Book Review: The Old Man and the Sea (Ernest Hemingway)

by J

This is a very mundane book, in that it has a simple plot. The entire book (127 pages) devotes itself to an old man's fight with a gigantic marlin.

Although, critics consider The Old Man and the Sea a classic, it was not enjoyable to read. The simple language, limited vocabulary, somber mood, and impractical plot were far from appealing. For instance, the old man acts as a superhuman with his strength and energy. Hemingway also used the word phosphorescent repeatedly.

On the other hand, the old man, Santiago, struggles with more than just the fish. His inner emotions are in turmoil. One must respect Hemingway for devising an uncomplicated plot to express a deeper, more troubling conflict. Santiago is actually battling the fish to regain his respect and self-worth within society.

Overall, this book is not worth reading. Nothing challenges the inner the mind when understanding/ analyzing the book. I suggest reading Hemingway's short story, "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber" instead.

No comments: